Properties For Sale in Plantation Key Colony, Islamorada

Elegant waterfront home in Islamorada with infinity pool, private dock, boat lift, and media room. Perfect for entertaining and enjoying the Florida Keys lifestyle. Direct bay and ocean access.

Luxury bayside 4-bedroom, 4-bathroom home in the Florida Keys. Boasting 4144 sq ft, sunset views, direct water access, a rooftop deck, separate living space, modern kitchen, durable construction, electric gate, and large boat dockage. Perfect for entertaining and water activities.

Luxury Balinese-inspired estate on Florida Bay. Spacious waterfront home with infinity pool, lush gardens, and private guest house. Boating access, close to amenities. Perfect for entertaining or relaxing.

Oceanfront acreage in Islamorada, Florida Keys! 7+ acres with 700ft of Atlantic beachfront and building rights. Create your dream estate with room for a main residence, guest houses, and more. Zoned for weekly rentals - a valuable investment opportunity!

Beautiful newly constructed cottage in downtown Islamorada! Features 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, a pool, and handicap access. Great for investment or personal use, close to shopping, restaurants, and more.

Oceanfront property on Lower Matecumbe Key with 300' of beachfront, including two vacant lots, a triplex, and 2 TDRs. Enjoy breathtaking ocean views, sandy beaches, and abundant wildlife. Perfect for redevelopment or a personal oasis.

Bayfront estate in Islamorada with breathtaking views. Fully fenced with private dock, tiki hut, pool, and multiple bedrooms and baths. Perfect for a Keys retreat or investment opportunity.

4 bed, 3.5 bath waterfront home in Islamorada. Freshly painted, new roof, impact windows, boat lift, top-of-the-line kitchen, and more! Perfect for entertaining.

Luxurious ocean view home on a point lot, offering over 6,000 sq ft of living space, 6 bedrooms, 5 bathrooms, and 4 oceanfront rooms. Features include soaring ceilings, large garage, putting green, elevator, deep water access with 2 boat lifts, beachfront and canal access, and a multi-million dollar renovation. Ideal for those seeking elegance and coastal bliss.

Beautiful 4-year-old, 3 bed, 2 bath home with all-wood cabinets, granite counters, stainless steel appliances, and marble floors. Large screened porch, LED lighting, ceiling fans, and handicap-accessible bathrooms. Two-car garage with front and back access, plus room for a pool. Low-maintenance landscaping and close to marinas, shopping, and restaurants.

Newly remodeled 3 bed, 3 bath home in Islamorada. Features open-concept living, spacious kitchen, large deck, and high-quality finishes. Perfect for entertaining and enjoying Florida's outdoor lifestyle. Close to restaurants and world-class fishing and diving.

Build your dream home on this 1.2-acre waterfront lot in Islamorada. Enjoy breathtaking sunsets, deep-water dockage, and a sandy beach. This lot is ready for construction and includes a TDR and Residential Estate zoning.

Islamorada bayfront property: 4-bed main house, 2-bed guest house, marble kitchen, infinity pool, spa, outdoor kitchen, boat basin with dock, waterfalls, whole-house generator. Perfect for families or those seeking a luxurious waterfront retreat.

Modern coastal masterpiece with 4 bedrooms, 4 bathrooms, private beach access, and 56' deepwater dockage. Room for a pool! Amazing sunsets!

Canalfront home with 65 ft. dock, access to neighborhood bayfront beach, and quick boating access to Florida Bay and the Atlantic. Features include impact windows/doors, 4 bedrooms, 3 baths, covered parking, garage, tackle room, and boat lifts. Room for a pool!

Oceanfront 1922 historic home with private beach, pool, and dock. Perfect for relaxation and water activities. Lush tropical setting on over an acre.

Updated Port Antigua home with open floor plan, 4 sets of sliding glass doors, Bosch stainless appliances, double granite counters, 90 ft. concrete dock with 10,000 lb. boatlift, and ample entertaining space. Ideal for those seeking a waterfront property with easy access to boating and outdoor activities.

3 acres of industrial upland & 9 acres of bayfront land (negotiable) with 150ft US1 frontage. Features plans for a 100' dock, two 30k lb boat lifts, and existing structures. Zoning permits over 30,000 sq ft construction. Suitable for various uses, including residential. Seller open to subdividing.

Fully renovated waterfront home in Lower Matecumbe Key. Boaters paradise with 75FT of dockage, 3 bedrooms, 3 baths, 2 kitchens, 2 laundry areas. New seawall and roof. Perfect for families or those seeking separate living spaces.

Luxury 4-bedroom, 2.5-bath home in the Florida Keys. Features 360-degree views, custom pool & spa, tiki hut, private elevator, dual boat lifts, and impact-resistant windows. Open-concept living space, guest suite, and secure garage.

Prime Lower Matecumbe Key property with direct ocean access, 60 ft deep-water dockage, and approved plans for a 3-bed, 2-bath home. Ideal for boaters, close to bridges. Lot is mostly scarified and ready to build.

Charming Old Florida cottage on Lower Matecumbe Key with 100 ft of private beach frontage. Two bedrooms, two bathrooms, beamed ceilings. Perfect fixer-upper or dream home opportunity. Enjoy breathtaking ocean views and the laid-back Florida Keys lifestyle.

Two-story waterfront property in the Florida Keys with three bedrooms and three baths, 1920 sq ft of living space, 6600 sq ft lot, 60 FT concrete dock with two boat lifts (10,000 lbs and 15,000 lbs), and ample parking. Suitable for boaters seeking ocean and bay access.

Waterfront retreat in Islamorada! This 3-bedroom, 2-bathroom home boasts stunning water views, a private boat ramp & dock, and a fenced yard with impact windows & doors. Perfect for boaters seeking a peaceful coastal lifestyle.

Classic Keys home with modern elegance. Three bedrooms, two baths. Spacious interior and exterior, lush landscaping. Walk to beaches, restaurants, and shopping. Ideal for relaxation and entertainment.

Dreamy Florida Keys harbor-front home! This serene Islamorada retreat boasts 2 upstairs suites with breathtaking views, plus a downstairs bedroom & party hut. Enjoy 99-ft concrete seawall, boat lift, and tranquil bay access. Perfect for waterfront living!

Island retreat in Islamorada! This 2-bedroom, 1-bathroom home boasts multiple decks, ocean views, a private pool, and a bonus studio. Perfect for families seeking privacy and convenience, with beach, tennis, and boat ramp access nearby.

Luxury waterfront home in Venetian Shores, Florida Keys. 3 bedrooms, 3 baths, furnished, boat slip, ocean access, and eco-friendly features. Perfect for full-time living, vacations, or investment.

Exquisitely remodeled 3-bedroom, 3-bath estate in Islamorada. Features new roof, electrical, impact windows, chef's kitchen, expansive lot, and rooftop deck. Enjoy easy access to world-class fishing and dining.

Osprey's Nest: Oceanfront Islamorada home with private dock, spacious floor plan, 3rd story primary suite, heated/chilled pool. Perfect for families seeking true island living.

Luxurious 4-bedroom, 3-bath home in Islamorada with 70ft private dockage, private beach access, pool, and expansive balcony. Ideal for families and investors seeking strong rental income.

Coastal retreat with 3 bedrooms, 3 bathrooms, open-concept design, expansive kitchen, screened balcony, 60-foot dock, boat ramp, pool, and propane generator. Perfect for fishing enthusiasts and those seeking a relaxing beach getaway.

Oceanfront 3BR, 2BA home with pool, covered patio, and gated privacy. Stunning beach & ocean views, fully remodeled in 2021 with impact windows, metal roof, new appliances & more. Coastal cottage style.

This inviting 2-bedroom, 2-bath CBS home in the desirable Indian Harbor Community is a standout value. Features include a metal roof, large storage, huge screened patio, massive veranda, and access to an exceptional HOA park with a boat ramp. Perfect for full-time, seasonal, or weekend living.

Islamorada oceanfront townhome condo with 3 bedrooms, 2 baths, private beach access, pool, and covered parking. Perfect for families seeking peace and privacy with stunning ocean views. Two rentals per year allowed with board approval.

Ultra-private bayfront estate in Islamorada offering expansive water views, deep-water dockage, infinity pool, gourmet kitchen, and storm resiliency features. Luxury living meets sustainable design.

Luxury beachfront home in Islamorada, Florida Keys. Six bedrooms, five bathrooms, three living rooms, private beach, pool, and stunning ocean views. Perfect for large families or groups. A lucrative investment opportunity.

Rare opportunity to build your dream home on this permitted lot in the desirable Bay Hammock community. This exclusive gated neighborhood offers a protected bayfront marina with a boat ramp, observation pier, and fillet table. An assigned boat slip is included! Don't miss out!

Gorgeous 4BR/3BA waterfront home with a guest suite, heated pool, and 70ft of dockage. Recently renovated with impact windows, concrete construction, and multiple lifts. Perfect for entertaining!

Beautifully remodeled ground-level duplex in Islamorada, offering two units plus a guest space. Durable concrete construction with impact windows and doors. Features a private fenced yard with artificial turf. Ideal as a permanent home or vacation retreat.